puppetmaker: (Doctow Who MS)
[personal profile] puppetmaker
But first my short review of the end of LOST. Spoiler free and I ask that the comments are the same. I’m OK with that explanation but I am not loving it since it was the one that they said it wasn’t after the first season but it really was but a slightly different version of it. Also, considering all the padding they had this season, the very end (aka the answer) seemed rather rushed. So not the best ending of all times nor the worst

Ok back to the good Doctor who has some issues (heck he has the whole subscription) deciding to helps some other people with their issues with mixed results for them and for him.

The costumes in this one were fun but the Beeb has always done well with costume drama. We get to know Rory better and it amazes me how polarizing that one character is in fandom. Personally, I am hoping that we get more time with Rory and Amy.

More about the villains in the spoilers section. They are doggone hard to talk about without spoilers really.

Anyway it looked good and again felt like an episode that you could drop just about any Doctor in and it would have worked. I think that is interesting that RTD’s Doctor Who was very much his playground and you couldn’t see another Doctor doing what his Doctor did but here Moffat is producing episodes that could be just about any of the Doctors probably with slightly different results. And I am enjoying that. It feels more connected to old Who than RTD’s run did (I’m not saying that RTD’s work is not Doctor Who or in the DW universe).

So in the immortal words of River Song

OK the Vampires who are not Vampires. I am OK with that but just OK. I was kind of disappointed that we weren’t picking up the Vampires of yore (State of Decay) even though they were in E-Space at the time (Raise you hand if you remember E-Space). But the explanation of who these creatures were and how they came to be was really interesting. So we can save the e-space critters for later.

I am liking Rory. He is playing the jilted lover but he doesn’t know if he is really jilted and he has an inferiority complex to the Raggedy Doctor. How can he hold a candle to someone who can travel through space and time? He does have courage and does deal with just the strangeness of traveling with the Doctor very well. I know he is around for a couple of episodes but I am honestly hoping he is there for the season. The third player this time doesn’t seem like a third wheel or contrived.

The themes of sacrifice and trust are again presented to us. How much do you trust me? How much can I trust you? What will you give to be with me? What will I give to make you happy?

Over all very happy with this one. Next we have Amy’s Choice.

I am grateful for new/old Who.

Date: 2010-05-25 12:18 am (UTC)
ext_18106: (Amy Pond thinks you might be ridiculous)
From: [identity profile] lyssie.livejournal.com
This episode had some very good lines, iirc. And it's catchier, as the time goes on.

I actually love the way Moffat's Who is more like the oldskool stuff.

Profile

puppetmaker: (Default)
puppetmaker

August 2025

S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
101112131415 16
1718 1920 21 22 23
24252627282930
31      

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Aug. 27th, 2025 05:02 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios